The Anna Maria Amcats football (often stylized as AmCats, AMCATS, or AMcats) teams represented Anna Maria College in American football during the program's second decade of college football from 2020 to present. The team competed as a member of the Eastern Collegiate Football Conference (ECFC) from 2009 to 2024 and as a member of the Massachusetts State Collegiate Athletic Conference (MASCAC) beginning in 2025. Highlights include the following:
Anna Maria play their home games at Caparso Field.
The head coaches were Dan Mulrooney (11–29) from 2017 to 2021, Steve Croce (14–14) from 2022 to 2024, and Tanner Kingsley from 2025 to present.
2020.
The 2020 Anna Maria Amcats football team was supposed to represent Anna Maria College of Paxton, Massachusetts. In what was going to be the fourth year under head coach Dan Mulrooney, Anna Maria cancelled their nine-game slate due to COVID-19.
2021.
The 2021 Anna Maria Amcats football team represented Anna Maria College of Paxton, Massachusetts. In its fifth and final year (fourth season) under head coach Dan Mulrooney, Anna Maria compiled an overall record of 7–3 as a member of the Eastern Collegiate Football Conference (ECFC) with a conference record of 5–1.
After leading Anna Maria to an overall record of 11–29, their first-ever winning season, first-ever conference championship, and first-ever playoff appearance, head coach Dan Mulrooney resigned to become the head coach for Lock Haven.
Head coach Dan Mulrooney was named ECFC Coach of the Year, while offensive coordinator and offensive line coach Steve Croce earned ECFC Assistant Coach of the Year. Wide receiver Deandre Wallace was selected as the ECFC Rookie of the Year and was also named First-team All-ECFC, along with defensive lineman Jude Sampson and defensive back Armstrong Antoine. Second-team All-ECFC selections included quarterback Alex Cohen, wide receiver Justin McMillian, offensive lineman Devin White, and defensive lineman Elijah Allston.
2022.
The 2022 Anna Maria Amcats football team represented Anna Maria College of Paxton, Massachusetts. In its first year under head coach Steve Croce, Anna Maria compiled an overall record of 5–4 as a member of the Eastern Collegiate Football Conference (ECFC) with a conference record of 3–3.
After six seasons on the staff, five as offensive coordinator, Steve Croce was promoted to head coach. Croce promoted quarterbacks coach Tanner Kingsley to replace him as offensive coordinator.
Wide receiver Devin Tolbert and offensive lineman Max Cyr were named First-team All-ECFC selections. Quarterback Alex Cohen, wide receiver Deandre Wallace, defensive linemen Terrence Jackson and Elijah Allston, linebackers Alvin Martin and Kyle Couto, and defensive back Lamar Wilkes earned Second-team All-ECFC honors.
2023.
The 2023 Anna Maria Amcats football team represented Anna Maria College of Paxton, Massachusetts. In its second year under head coach Steve Croce, Anna Maria compiled an overall record of 5–5 as a member of the Eastern Collegiate Football Conference (ECFC) with a conference record of 3–1.
Head coach Steve Croce was named ECFC Coach of the Year, while offensive coordinator and quarterbacks coach Tanner Kingsley earned ECFC Assistant Coach of the Year. Quarterback Ryan Russell was recognized as the ECFC Offensive Player of the Year, and offensive lineman Max Cyr was named ECFC Offensive Lineman of the Year. Kicker Ryan Kent received ECFC Special Teams Player of the Year honors.
Several Amcats were selected to the All-ECFC First Team, including quarterback Ryan Russell, running back Jamal Cariglia, wide receivers Deandre Wallace and Mark Johnson-Morgan, offensive linemen Max Cyr and Da'Shawn Allen, kicker Ryan Kent, defensive linemen Elijah Allston and Malik Kirnon, linebacker Antonio Giano, and defensive back Lamar Wilkes. Second-team All-ECFC selections included running back Justin Brown, tight end Tyler Bulinski, offensive lineman Timothy Northrup, linebacker Dilaver Ibrahimi, and defensive back Rashawn Shelton.
2024.
The 2024 Anna Maria Amcats football team represented Anna Maria College of Paxton, Massachusetts. In its third and final year under head coach Steve Croce, Anna Maria compiled an overall record of 4–5 as a member of the Eastern Collegiate Football Conference (ECFC) with a conference record of 2–1.
Midway through the season, Croce announced his intentions to retire. Croce ended his tenure with an overall record of 14–14 including one bowl game appearance. Associate head coach, offensive coordinator, and quarterbacks coach Tanner Kingsley was quickly promoted to head coach for the 2025 season.
Anna Maria's season ended with a 39–37 loss to Alfred State in the first, and final, ECFC Championship. The Amcats were led by quarterback Ryan Russell, the ECFC Offensive Player of the Year and a First-team All-ECFC selection, who threw for 2,777 yards and 27 touchdowns in his second season as a starter. Kicker Ryan Kent earned ECFC Special Teams Player of the Year honors, while defensive back Di'Angelo Jean Pierre was named co-Rookie of the Year. Several players received all-conference recognition: First-team All-ECFC selections included running back Jamal Cariglia, wide receivers Justin Oliver, Kevin Acosta Jr., and Davien Atkinson, offensive lineman Max Cyr, return specialist Justin Oliver, defensive lineman Jordan Martin, and defensive back Jihad Brown. Second-team All-ECFC honorees were running back Nico Cavaliere, wide receiver David Robinson, tight end Tyler Garretson, offensive linemen Timothy Northrup and Nathan Kern, defensive lineman Gabriel Mendez, and linebackers Kellen Palm and Jaiquan Torrence.
This was the final season as a member of the ECFC, as the three other teams were leaving the conference. Anna Maria was accepted as a full member of the Massachusetts State Collegiate Athletic Conference (MASCAC) starting in the 2025 season.
2025.
The 2025 Anna Maria Amcats football team will represent Anna Maria College of Paxton, Massachusetts. In its first year under head coach Tanner Kingsley, Anna Maria will compete as a member of the Massachusetts State Collegiate Athletic Conference (MASCAC).
This was the school's first season as a member of the Massachusetts State Collegiate Athletic Conference (MASCAC).